Pesticides, herbicides, chlorine rinses…

Navigating the produce aisle has turned into an endless search for ‘pure’ fruits and vegetables free scary-sounding chemicals.

 Photo:  Scott Warman

As we become more wary, it’s important to consider what we’re voting for with our hard-earned dollars. How bad are these chemicals for humans? How about the environment? What are we willing to sacrifice to ensure our produce is safe to eat?

We decided to take a look into the two most common types of chemicals found in our food to see if it’s worth paying the extra dollar for organic, or locally-grown produce.


1. Chlorine rinses

A chlorine rinse is a combination of water and chlorine bleach. It is used to rinse produce in order reduce the chances of us consuming potentially harmful bacterias found on fresh food (such as E.coli and Salmonella). These chlorine bleach solutions typically contain either sodium hypochlorite or chlorine dioxide.

Unfortunately, chlorine rinses are not that effective: only 10 percent of bacteria is removed with a bleach solution (and we can all remember the country-wide E.coli scare this year). And if E.coli isn’t unappetizing enough, occasionally traces of the stronger cleaners can remain on the food. Since bleach, even diluted in water, can be toxic, it’s highly recommended to rewash fresh foods before eating them.

 Photo:  Biocell Water

So, is it safe to eat?

The short answer is: yes. The FDA’s formula for chlorine bleach rinses is 1 tsp - 1 Tbsp of fresh (less 6 months old), unscented bleach for every gallon of water. The fresh produce should be soaked in this solution for 10 minutes, and then rinsed thoroughly in another bowl with running water for 5 minutes. When used this way, chlorine bleach is safe to consume.

The longer answer is: yes, BUT this method is largely ineffective: it is enough to wash and scrub fresh produce with clean water. Additionally, cooking fresh produce is often enough to kill any unwanted microorganisms.

This method can also be dangerous. While we consume very low levels of chlorine bleach in our food, individual workers who rinse and package treated produce are exposed to higher, more dangerous, concentrations. The two active ingredients in bleach can cause several negative health outcomes, including skin irritation, blisters, burning pain, sore throat, coughing, and general respiratory distress.

The use of chlorine bleach can also lead to environmental pollution. Sodium hypochlorite is particularly damaging to the environment. It is a registered pesticide that is toxic to freshwater fish and invertebrates, and poisonous to plants.

If that doesn’t sound bad enough, sodium hypochlorite increases soil pH and breaks down to form hypochlorite. Additional chemical reactions cause hypochlorite to produce and release carcinogenic molecules (trihalomethanes) into the atmosphere.


2. Pesticides

We’re all familiar with this term, but pesticides are actually a group of different chemicals. The main pesticide groups are antimicrobials, fungicides, herbicides, and insecticides (see the full list!).

When it comes to the food system, pests affect productivity by eating or spoiling otherwise good crops. Additionally, pests like rodents or mosquitoes can carry bacteria and viruses that are dangerous to our health. Pesticides decrease this risk and make food last longer in storage. In doing all this, pesticides “improve” the quality of food: think about a worm-eaten apple compared to an untouched one, which one would you rather eat?!).

 Photo:  Civil Eats

Photo: Civil Eats

So, is it safe to eat?

The short answer is: yes, BUT. The majority of the fresh fruits and vegetables we eat contain minimal traces of pesticides. At such low concentrations, these pesticides aren’t toxic to humans and can be washed away with water.

However, 'barely' there, is still there. The FDA has reported that 54 percent of fruit and 36 percent of vegetables arrive at our plates with traces of pesticides still on them. Furthermore, lettuce tests by the USDA found residues from 52 different pesticides that have health and environmental risk factors:

  • 3 known or probable carcinogens

  • 17 suspected hormone disruptors

  • 10 neurotoxins

  • 8 developmental or reproductive toxins

  • 14 honeybee toxins.

And it’s not just one type of pesticide per crop. An apple, for example, can be sprayed up to 16 times with 30 different chemicals.

Sometimes these fresh foods don’t get washed or processed correctly before ending up at the grocery store. In one case, USDA researchers found lettuce in the market with concentrations of a toxic pesticide (Oxydemeton methyl) at more than twice the dose deemed safe for a six year old child. While this isn't the usual case, it goes to show that dangerous pesticides can make it onto our plates in significant quantities.

The longer answer is: let’s stay as far away from pesticides as possible. While eating an apple or a salad without washing the produce first isn't inherently harmful, pesticides are very dangerous for people living or working near pesticide-treated farmland. Pesticide poisoning is widespread and can be deadly: every year, approximately 200,000 fatal pesticide poisoning cases occur worldwide (it’s likely more, but many cases likely go unreported). Additionally, long-term exposure to pesticides can make you very sick:

  • Pesticide exposure can induce oxidative stress. This is turn can cause diabetes, high blood pressure, heart disease, neurodegenerative diseases (like Parkinson’s and Alzheimer's), cancer and more.

  • Additionally, pesticide exposure can disrupt the human endocrine system and cause reproductive problems.

  • Pesticide exposure can lead to mood disorders, depression, anxiety, and suicide. So, all around, bad stuff.

 Photo:  Aaron Burden

If this is what pesticides can do to humans, think of the effects they have on other species! Pesticide usage to target real pests (that kill crops or spread disease) doesn't occur in a vacuum.  Killing the intended pest can lead to negative impacts for many other ‘innocent’ animals and insects. Bees are an example of the terrible environmental impact of pesticides: in 2015-2016 alone, the U.S. bee population decreased by 44 percent. Compare this statistic with the rampant use of  Imidacloprid (found of 48 percent of grapes and 20 percent of apples), Bifenthrin (found on 24 percent of strawberries and 25 percent of cherry tomatoes), both bee toxins– and a grim picture of the effects of pesticides becomes clear.

Pesticides often create negative environmental effects far outside their application zones. This because the chemicals infiltrate surface and groundwater, and break down into the atmosphere at large. This creates ecological stress for surrounding plants, insects, birds, and mammals. Pesticides can also be ingested second hand (ex. a bird or fish eating an affected insect).


What’s the verdict?

The experts agree: the benefits of eating fresh fruits and vegetables outweigh the potential risks of consuming the chemicals used in the growing and packaging process. So, if you’re limited in your spending, stick to the ‘standard’ options in the produce aisle!

However, if you’re able to spend the extra dollar or two, opt for organic–or even better–local produce.

Local or organic?

In both instances, you’re eliminating harmful chemicals from your own diet, while also choosing to avoid buying into farming methods that are harmful for workers and the environment alike.

Organic is a regulated term; you need to prove that you are following specific guidelines. These generally include natural resources, conserving biodiversity, and using only approved substances (full guidelines here). However, as consumers increasingly look to buy organic, the once community-centered practice has become less environmentally sustainable. Today, Big Organic uses huge centralized operations to supply growing demands. Fresh produce ends up traveling thousands of miles, which not only affects the food’s quality and nutritional values, but also contributes to greenhouse gases (thus undermining the idea of eco-friendly farming). 

On the other hand, local food does not have this problem. While local can mean many things to many people, it’s largely centered around the idea of growing and selling produce to the immediate community. This has translated to people choosing to identify as ‘locavores’, or participating in 100-mile diets. This point of view not only prioritizes chemical-free farming, but also encourages small and local businesses to flourish and entire communities to come together around sharing good food.

 
  Big Organic farm  Photo:  Genetic Literacy Project

Big Organic farm
Photo: Genetic Literacy Project

  Small local farm  Photo:  Michael Bourgault

Small local farm
Photo: Michael Bourgault

It’s important to note that local and organic aren’t mutually exclusive. Many local farms operate using organic principles. However, don’t limit your purchasing behavior to just organic produce.

Many small farmers choose not to go through the long and expensive process of getting a USDA organic certification, even though they follow all the rules. Organic is also a term that is very rarely applied to alternative farming methods, like hydroponics or aquaponics, even though neither require the use of any kind of chemicals.


Interested in going local?

Check out this Eat Wild guide to find pasture-raised meat in your area. You can also use this USDA farmers market directory to for sourcing fresh produce! And, if you’re a business looking to source local food, check out Grown by Freight Farms, our hydroponic farming service that puts a farm right at your location.

Related articles

Bringing Local Back to the Island
Everyday is World Environment Day
We Found the ‘Lost’ Generation of Farmers
Women Changing the Farm-to-Table Movement

Comment